Post Your Cases > Prophylactic Intralipid to prevent cardiac toxicity?
Hi Karlon. Thanks for posting this interesting case. First, this was a deja vu for me, having had a nearly identical case about 3 years ago...not a Bier, but a brachial plexus block. My jaw dropped and heart skipped when I looked at the emply bottles of 0.75% bupiv after doing a 40mL injection. The resident was a newbie and didn't know we had planned to use mepivacaine (of course, now ew have NO 0.75% anywhere except the little spinal amps). Fortunately, mine was in the plexus, NOT intravascular so I feel for you....PTSD is not unexpected.
I think you handled the situation perfectly. The only other suggestion I might offer is trying to arrange for cardiopulmonary bypass in advance of letting the tourniquet down should the lipid not prophylax adequately. However, this is only a consideration if you are located at a facility that has capability. Regardless, I think a large dose of lipid by bolus and infusion prior to incremental, short cuff deflations makes perfect sense. One could also contemplate using a saline intravenous 'wash' but I'm not sure how that would be done of if it could be effective (viz, saline into a hand veing - maybe where you injected the local - and then out a subclavian vv catheter. Not sure that has ever been reported, and probably wouldn't provide much protection, but it's somethign to think about. Your case also brings up a variety of other topics:
First, once again, communication issues are at the heart of a potentially fatal, sentinel event. My case was a matter of assuming and we all know what a mistake that is.
Second, you've presented, to my knowledge, the FIRST example of lipid pretreatment in a human prior to a bupivacaine challenge. This makes it just like the original rat expts ~ a decade ago showing that lipid pretreatment prevents bupivacaine toxicity.
Third, there's NO question in my mind that the bradycardia you saw was an OMINOUS prelude to what was coming (250mg intravenous bupivacaine would be my absolute nightmare). Fortunately, you had the prescience to take action....congrats on saving a life (and avoiding depositions).
Finally....you should write this up, at leaast as a letter to the editor. It is highly instructive and you should publish the concept of PRE-treatment for such potential catastrophes.
Oh, and one more thing....make the CRNA student do 100 pushups and write 1000 times, 'bupivacaine is cardiotoxic'.
Thanks for sharing.
Guy
I think you handled the situation perfectly. The only other suggestion I might offer is trying to arrange for cardiopulmonary bypass in advance of letting the tourniquet down should the lipid not prophylax adequately. However, this is only a consideration if you are located at a facility that has capability. Regardless, I think a large dose of lipid by bolus and infusion prior to incremental, short cuff deflations makes perfect sense. One could also contemplate using a saline intravenous 'wash' but I'm not sure how that would be done of if it could be effective (viz, saline into a hand veing - maybe where you injected the local - and then out a subclavian vv catheter. Not sure that has ever been reported, and probably wouldn't provide much protection, but it's somethign to think about. Your case also brings up a variety of other topics:
First, once again, communication issues are at the heart of a potentially fatal, sentinel event. My case was a matter of assuming and we all know what a mistake that is.
Second, you've presented, to my knowledge, the FIRST example of lipid pretreatment in a human prior to a bupivacaine challenge. This makes it just like the original rat expts ~ a decade ago showing that lipid pretreatment prevents bupivacaine toxicity.
Third, there's NO question in my mind that the bradycardia you saw was an OMINOUS prelude to what was coming (250mg intravenous bupivacaine would be my absolute nightmare). Fortunately, you had the prescience to take action....congrats on saving a life (and avoiding depositions).
Finally....you should write this up, at leaast as a letter to the editor. It is highly instructive and you should publish the concept of PRE-treatment for such potential catastrophes.
Oh, and one more thing....make the CRNA student do 100 pushups and write 1000 times, 'bupivacaine is cardiotoxic'.
Thanks for sharing.
Guy
June 10, 2007 |
[Guy Weinberg]
Guy, thanks for your reply and confirmation that my chosen course of action was not unreasonable. This case occurred at a small rural hospital that does not do thoracic or vascular, much less cardiac cases. The thought about transferring this patient to a medical center with CPB capbility did occur but the closest facility is about 45 min away.
I hope that no one else will have to experience what I went through, but at least this case can provide some guidance to others. Thanks again,
Karlon Young
I hope that no one else will have to experience what I went through, but at least this case can provide some guidance to others. Thanks again,
Karlon Young
June 10, 2007 |
Karlon Young
Karlon: a few questions (a brilliant save by the way; as I was reading your report I was struck by the impossibly difficult spot you were in, and I too thought of the unexploded bomb) 1) were both tourniquets inflated to 250 mm Hg during injection of local, or only one, and which one? 2) where was the intravenous catheter you used for local injection relative to the tourniquet? In the hand, or closer to the tourniquets? 3) were either of the 2 tourniquets deflated/reinflated (e.g., for tourniquet pain) after the bupivacaine injection, but before your controlled deflations? 4) was this a young, healthy patient or something else?
I'm trying to figure out how bupivacaine could have gained access to the circulation under the tourniquet to produce the initial bradycardia. Thanks. Again, a nice job 'defusing' a potentially lethal situation.
Tim
I'm trying to figure out how bupivacaine could have gained access to the circulation under the tourniquet to produce the initial bradycardia. Thanks. Again, a nice job 'defusing' a potentially lethal situation.
Tim
June 11, 2007 |
Tim VadeBoncouer
Hi Karlon,
One more thought...
when I was a resident at UVa, I remember being told of a bupivacaine bier block gone bad at a nearby hospital when someone knocked over the CO2 tank causing rapid deflation and fatal bupivacaine overdose....young patient as i recall. the lesson he was teaching me then was: no bupivacaine for bier blocks. there is some literature on this, too. but it goes way back. anyway, there is NO chance you would've avoided chest compressions by just letting the cuff down (incrementally or not) without some intervention: lipid or CPP.
i reiterate: your case is sufficiently instructive to warrant publication...go at least for the letter to the editor if not a case report. do you have ecg tracings?
g
One more thought...
when I was a resident at UVa, I remember being told of a bupivacaine bier block gone bad at a nearby hospital when someone knocked over the CO2 tank causing rapid deflation and fatal bupivacaine overdose....young patient as i recall. the lesson he was teaching me then was: no bupivacaine for bier blocks. there is some literature on this, too. but it goes way back. anyway, there is NO chance you would've avoided chest compressions by just letting the cuff down (incrementally or not) without some intervention: lipid or CPP.
i reiterate: your case is sufficiently instructive to warrant publication...go at least for the letter to the editor if not a case report. do you have ecg tracings?
g
June 11, 2007 |
[Guy Weinberg]
Tim,
The patient is a 50 yr old female in relative good health except for being a one pack/day smoker.
The i.v. catheter was placed distally in the hand. The proximal cuff was inflated after the distal cuff was inflated and then the distal cuff was deflated. The local was injected at this point (with only the proximal cuff inflated). The distal cuff was not re-inflated, nor was the proximal cuff deflated to deal with tourniquet pain. The patient never complained of tourniquet pain. She was sedated with a continuous propofol infusion throughout the procedure. The propofol was stopped at the onset of the bradycardia.
I do not have the ECG tracings, but I am pretty certain that the QRS was not widening. I don't recall what was going on with the QT interval.
Karlon
The patient is a 50 yr old female in relative good health except for being a one pack/day smoker.
The i.v. catheter was placed distally in the hand. The proximal cuff was inflated after the distal cuff was inflated and then the distal cuff was deflated. The local was injected at this point (with only the proximal cuff inflated). The distal cuff was not re-inflated, nor was the proximal cuff deflated to deal with tourniquet pain. The patient never complained of tourniquet pain. She was sedated with a continuous propofol infusion throughout the procedure. The propofol was stopped at the onset of the bradycardia.
I do not have the ECG tracings, but I am pretty certain that the QRS was not widening. I don't recall what was going on with the QT interval.
Karlon
June 12, 2007 |
Karlon Young
Dr. Young:
I am a member of Dr. Weinberg's lab, and am composing an editorial on lipid rescue for submission to an anesthesiology newsletter. I think this case is especially compelling, and would love to include mention of it if you are alright with it. Please let me know here or by email if you would be supportive- not a formal case report, but more anecdotal mention. Thanks a bunch.
Luke Edelman
I am a member of Dr. Weinberg's lab, and am composing an editorial on lipid rescue for submission to an anesthesiology newsletter. I think this case is especially compelling, and would love to include mention of it if you are alright with it. Please let me know here or by email if you would be supportive- not a formal case report, but more anecdotal mention. Thanks a bunch.
Luke Edelman
June 15, 2007 |
Luke Edelman
Karlon,
are you going to write up your case?
Guy
are you going to write up your case?
Guy
July 1, 2007 |
Guy Weinberg
Yikes!!!! At least the mistake was picked up BEFORE the tournequet was deflated. Good, quick thinking.
September 21, 2007 |
Q. McCutchen
Very well done. I can report a similar case wherein bupivacaine was erroneously infused in a Biers block with disasterous result (before lipid rescue!).
I wonder what your thoughts are on lipid infusion to the ipsilateral limb prior to cuff deflation, in addition to systemically. Drug sequestration to lipid before potential systemic bolus with re-establishment of limb perfusion may have further de-fused the bomb. Just a thought.
I wonder what your thoughts are on lipid infusion to the ipsilateral limb prior to cuff deflation, in addition to systemically. Drug sequestration to lipid before potential systemic bolus with re-establishment of limb perfusion may have further de-fused the bomb. Just a thought.
January 28, 2008 |
Martyn Harvey
well done
It is always better to prevent a complication than treating it when it occurs. I was wondering if we can give at least some intralipid intravenously before tournquet release. God bless you
Dr Ali Lashari
Dept of Anesthesia
Jinnah Hospital
Lahore, Pakistan
It is always better to prevent a complication than treating it when it occurs. I was wondering if we can give at least some intralipid intravenously before tournquet release. God bless you
Dr Ali Lashari
Dept of Anesthesia
Jinnah Hospital
Lahore, Pakistan
August 30, 2009 |
Dr Ali Lashari
There were no hemodynamic changes. BP remained 95-110 systolic with HR 66-70.
Intralipid, 250 ml had been administered prior to tourniquet deflation. The patient's weight was 150 lbs. Another 250 mls of Intralipid was infused upon transfer to PACU. The patient continued to remain awake and alert for two and one half hours in PACU without hemodynamic or ECG changes. The patient was offered an overnight observation bed, but because she was asymptomatic and felt well she elected to go home. Follow up by phone the next morming revealed no subsequent problems. Sensation and movement had returned to the extremity but this occurred several hours after discharge.
I wanted to post this case because it felt like I was being asked to defuse an unexploded bomb. I don't know that the bradycadia exhibited by the patient was a warning or just an aberration. I was still faced with the problem of what to do upon tourniquet deflation. Perhaps I could have kept the tourniquet inflated but for how long? I used the bradycardia as a sign of impending cardiac complications and that keeping the tourniquet inflated may not influence the outcome as the patient was already exhibiting signs of cardiac
toxicity. However, I did want to get Intralipid on board before tourniquet deflation in order to ameliorate any further problems.
I welcome your thoughts on how you would have dealt with this dilemma, i.e.,treat prophylactically as I had done, or deflate the tourniquet and treat any complications that may susequently arise.